Today Marshmallow reviews The Cartoonists Club by Raina Telgemeier and Scott McCloud, first published in 2025.
Marshmallow reviews The Cartoonists Club by Raina Telgemeier and Scott McCloud.
Marshmallow’s Quick Take: If you like cartoons, art, or graphic novels, then this is the book for you!
Marshmallow’s Summary (with Spoilers): Makayla’s mind is always overflowing with new ideas for stories but Howard is the one who keeps passing her doodles during math class. One day, after they finally get caught by their algebra teacher, they decide to make their own comic book. When they meet up at their middle school’s library after school, Makayla reveals her master plan: they are going to form a club for the other students in their school who want to be cartoonists too. With the help of the kind librarian, they print out their posters and wait for the next day to see if anyone shows up.
Luckily, someone does! Art is an agender artist who loves “making mistakes” and can’t wait to make them in another new forum. The three of them become friends quickly and can’t wait to start making comic books. Unfortunately, they are extremely puzzled and ask the librarian what the “right” way to proceed is. To their surprise, she informs them that there is no right way at all. Through this newfound freedom, they proceed to produce numerous silly but fun short comics.
They also are able to welcome in a new member: Lynda. She’d been in the library since day one, drawing quietly in a corner, but had been too nervous to show anyone her art. Since she focused so heavily on the mistakes she made, she was too scared to show any part of her art at all.
As the story progresses, each of the characters’ artistic struggles are revealed and remediated through a group effort. The Cartoonists Club is a heartwarming, inspiring story perfect for any and all young artists interested in drawing. It is the ideal guide for young bunnies looking to find and create communities much like the one in this book!
Marshmallow is reading The Cartoonists Club by Raina Telgemeier and Scott McCloud.
Marshmallow’s Review: I think The Cartoonists Club is a very cute book! The characters’ interest in comics and their making is a bit infectious in fact. I’ve always appreciated graphic novels and the like, but reading The Cartoonists Club has made me appreciate how much of an art they really are.
I really liked how different aspects of the art were highlighted in different chapters. In almost every section, the librarian or one of the club members teaches the club and the reader about how to perfect another aspect of cartoons. I especially liked the section that talked about the magic of the blank page. It was simple yet inspiring in a way that recalls the childlike awe too many of us lose as we grow older.
I think The Cartoonists Club is a perfect book for all young bunnies who love drawing or reading or learning! And while it might at first seem too childish for those older than twelve, I think there is still a lot of value in reading it. As a bunny who is no longer in middle school, reading The Cartoonists Club was still very inspiring and made me remember how important art is to me and to us as bunnies / humans. It is a relatively easy book to read and you can read it pretty quickly. But just because it is short and sweet doesn’t mean that its story isn’t significant; sometimes remembering that ‘childish’ sense of imagination is just what you need to recall that same passion and joyful outlook on life!
Marshmallow’s Rating: 100%.
Marshmallow rates The Cartoonists Club by Raina Telgemeier and Scott McCloud 100%.
A while back Caramel read and reviewed Katherine Rundell’s book titled Impossible Creatures. Today he is talking to Sprinkles about the sequel, The Poisoned King, published originally in 2025.
Caramel reviews The Poisoned King by Katherine Rundell.
Caramel: Yup, it is also just as good as the first one.
S: I love it when that happens! So tell me a bit about this book. You had said that the previous book had ended a bit sad. Does this one pick up where that one ended and maybe things get happier?
C: No, I think it’s a little later, maybe a year or so.
S: The same characters?
C: Yes, some of them are the same.
S: Great! So there is some continuity. That is good. So tell us about the story.
C: Yeah, so in the beginning, there is a girl named Anya who is a princess, and her grandfather is killed. So Anya tries to figure out who did that.
S: So is Anya’s grandfather the poisoned king in the title?
C: Yes.
S: So how does Christopher from the other book show up?
C: He doesn’t show up for a while. But we are in the same world and same archipelago.
S: Ooh, and are the same magical creatures from that book still here?
C: Yes.
S: Is the whole book about Anya trying to find who poisoned her grandfather?
C: Sort of. But there are also dragons dying from the same poison.
S: Hmm, kind of like the first book where the magical creatures were in danger.
C: Yeah, except the dragons’ gold is also being stolen.
S: That is interesting! So multiple mysteries all at once.
C: Yeah, but all connected.
S: That makes sense.
Caramel is reading The Poisoned King by Katherine Rundell.
S: So in the first book there were a lot of illustrations and you really liked them. Are there any in this one, too?
C: Yeah, it’s like the first one where the pictures are shown only when an important event is described. They are done by the same person, Ashley MacKenzie, and they are just as good. But again, it could have been nice to have more of them.
S: Yeah, I see. Did the book end in a cliffhanger?
C: Yes, it sort of did so there has to be a third book and I have to read it!
S: Yes, apparently there is a third book and it is coming out this September. Its name is The Neverfear.
C: That is a strange title. The other two titles were more regular titles. I wonder what Neverfear means. But yay! I really have to read that book!
S: I am glad you liked this book that much Caramel. So it was fun to read?
C: Yes! I mean, they have magic and they have dragons! Who wouldn’t like that?
S: I know, right? Okay, so before we wrap up this review, tell me if a reader could read this second book before reading the first one. Would it still work? Or should they read the first book before diving into this one?
C: it would be good to have read the first one. You’d have a better understanding of the world. And the characters and the stories from the first book come up here, too, so this second book would not make as much sense to someone who has not read the first book.
S: I see, thank you Caramel, that makes sense. So let us wrap it up then. What would you like to tell our readers?
C: Stay tuned for more book bunny reviews!
Caramel enjoyed reading The Poisoned King by Katherine Rundell and is looking forward to the third and last installment of this trilogy.
Today Marshmallow reviews The Archer, a short book originally written in 2003 by Paulo Coelho, illustrated by Christoph Niemann, and translated into English by Margaret Jull Costa.
Marshmallow reviews The Archer, written by Paulo Coelho, illustrated by Christoph Niemann, and translated into English by Margaret Jull Costa.
Marshmallow’s Quick Take: If you like simple yet somewhat profound books, then this is the book for you!
Marshmallow’s Summary (with Spoilers): At the beginning of this story, a stranger seeks out Tetsuya. Tetsuya is a humble carpenter now, but he used to be famous throughout the land for his prodigious gifts with a bow and arrow. His sudden retirement and disappearance were rather mysterious, but he is content to live in quiet and obscurity. The stranger searching for him is determined to find him though. He asks a boy from the town to take him to the carpenter and the two arrive at his shop. The stranger pleads Tetsuya to watch him shoot, saying he has mastered the way of the bow and merely wants Tetsuya’s approval to know that his training is complete. To show his worth, the stranger shoots a cherry off a cherry tree a certain distance away. Tetsuya calmly agrees and leads both the stranger and the boy up the mountain in silence. They arrive at a fraying bridge traversing a perilous river and Tetsuya walks to the middle. He shoots a peach off a tree only half the previous distance away from him. He asks the stranger to do the same, but the stranger fails. Tetsuya then tells him that he has mastered the bow but not his mind. With that lesson, he sends the stranger off, after having him promise to keep his identity secret.
The boy—who had been unaware of Tetsuya’s archery prowess till then—is awestruck and asks to be taught the way of the bow. As the master and young boy begin their long trek back to his shop, Tetsuya explains some of the founding ideals of the way of the bow and life as whole. After all, “the way of the bow is present in any human activity.”
Marshmallow is reading The Archer, written by Paulo Coelho, illustrated by Christoph Niemann, and translated into English by Margaret Jull Costa.
Marshmallow’s Review:The Archer was an intriguing book. To be entirely honest, some of the advice is a little too vague and seemed slightly generic. I think a lot of what the author said has been said before, just in different ways.
The pictures by Christoph Niemann were very pretty though, and the minimalistic illustrative style was very calming to look at. They were, I thought, often unrelated to the text, but you can find connections between any two things if you look hard enough.
This goes for this entire book. The text is short and simple with only a couple words or a paragraph per page, making it very spread out. There are 130 or 131 pages but it does not take a lot of time to read at all. If one were to put all words into standard book pages, you would probably not need to go beyond 30-40 pages max.
The Archer is very calming to read. However, the advice and wisdom feels very simplistic and slightly obvious. I feel like this experience is very inspiring if you are willing to analyze every word, every page, every picture and infuse it with your own meaning. If you work hard to interpret everything in a new way, in a way besides the true simple meaning, then you might emerge with a new perspective on life. Without that kind of effort on the side of the reader, most of the text felt like a repetition of ideas that most people have already heard. That said, it was still nice to read. I just don’t know how truly novel this book is.
Marshmallow’s Rating: 94%.
Marshmallow rates The Archer, written by Paulo Coelho, illustrated by Christoph Niemann, and translated into English by Margaret Jull Costa, 94%.
Many years ago, in the very early days of this blog Caramel reviewed a classic, Harold and the Purple Crayon, by Crockett Johnson. Today he is talking to Sprinkles about a sequel of sorts, Harold at the North Pole, published originally in 1957.
Caramel reviews Harold at the North Pole by Crockett Johnson.
Sprinkles: I was so excited to find this little book last week! So even though it is a Christmas book and we are nowhere close to Christmas, I thought it would be fun to talk about it today.
Caramel: Yup. And I agreed. Because who doesn’t want to talk about Santa Claus and snow and Christmas gifts?
S: I know, right? I mean we just couldn’t wait till December.. Anyways, our readers probably remember Harold, the little boy in blue overalls who creates the world around him with his ginormous purple crayon.
C: Yeah, I would expect so. You and I talked about Harold and the Purple Crayon all the way back in 2020, so if they don’t remember, they can just read our old post.
S: Yep. That was right around the time the pandemic really took off!
C: Yeah, the pandemic was around that time, which was pretty terrible. But the book was really good. And later, we also saw the live-action movie, which was actually pretty good.
S: Yeah, I remember watching it with you and liking it. It seems like the critics didn’t like it much, but we enjoyed it.
C: Yup, we did. Maybe you can put a link to the trailer in the post?
S: Sure. Here is the trailer of the movie:
Harold and The Purple Crayon: official trailer, from YouTube.
C: Thanks. It was fun to watch.
S: So let us get back to Harold at the North Pole.
C: Sure. So this is about Harold, the very same little boy, But in the cover this time he is wearing green overalls, and a red hat. Very Christmas-y!
S: Yeah, he is not in his blue overalls any more, but you are right, the red-green fits the holiday season very well. And the crayon is still purple, right?
C: Yup. So this time, Harold wants to find a Christmas tree before Santa can visit his home. So he goes out and tries to find a tree. Along the way he finds himself at the North Pole and ends up helping Santa. He also helps draw up Santa’s reindeer and a sleigh full of presents. And finally he gets back home and settles down near a fireplace to wait for Santa.
S: Yep. That sounds about right.
C: Actually I think it kind of sounds a bit eerie. The boy is always alone, and there is nobody and nothing around him until he draws them. It is almost like a scary dream.
Caramel is reading Harold at the North Pole by Crockett Johnson.
S: Wait, if you read it like that, then it does not come across like a cute, warm, and fuzzy story.
C: No, it doesn’t. And when you look back at the first book, that also could be the same, with Harold all alone, making stuff up as he goes around living all alone. Abandoned.
S: Hmm, yes, I can see that. But it is not really the real world that he is in, is it? He is not all alone in a scary way really. I think maybe we are in Harold’s imaginary world, as he is recreating the world. The transitions from home, to the northern woods, to the North Pole, back home would be dizzying if real. But they are not. Harold just flows smoothly from one place to the other, as smoothly as he can draw something.
C: Or actually he does not flow anywhere and the places just smoothly flow around him as he draws them. Yes, I know, it is not really about a little child all alone in a scary way, but I just wanted to say it would be kind of weird if this were real.
S: I guess that is why the movie version made the situation so weird. Nobody would believe the grown-up Harold.
C: I wouldn’t. But you know, if the crayon were real, it would be really cool! And dangerous! All those bad people who were after the crayon in the movie, it totally makes sense, because the crayon is so powerful if you can create reality all by drawing something.
S: Yes.
C: So okay, the books are really sweet, they are not scary at all. I just wanted to say they are also a bit weird, but when read in their own story world, they are really sweet. And I think any little bunny would enjoy imagining themselves with a purple crayon and trying to figure out what they would draw with it and going into adventures with it and so on.
S: Yeah, for sure. So what would you draw with it if you had the purple crayon?
C: I would draw the seventeenth book of Wings of Fire; lock in Sutherland!
S: Not sure it works that way, Caramel…
C: Dang it. Still, lock in Sutherland, I love those books, come out with more, please.
S: Okay, maybe she will some day. She has to go forth with the new story arc she started in the sixteenth book anyways. But so you wouldn’t draw anything else? I could draw an ice cream machine that makes ice cream for me, a bubble bath, a beautiful sunset, a comfy big chair, and lots of books and bookshelves around it where I could read.. I can go on forever!
C: Well, Sprinkles, we do have lots of books and bookshelves in our house, and there is a comfy chair nearby too.
S: Yes, I know we are lucky. And maybe the things Harold draws are also kind of homelike, like a fireplace, and an armchair to sit on, and his home is also a regular home, just comfy.
C: Like our home. Our home is comfy too.
S: True… Okay, so overall what did you think of this book?
C: It is cute. It would even make sense to a young person who has not read the original book, but if the young person liked that first book, they would definitely enjoy reading this around the holidays. It would make a good Christmas gift.
S: Yeah, it is kind of surreal, but young bunnies can get into surreal stories very quickly.
C: Yeah, just ignore the probable psychological implications of why Harold has no parents, friends or any other people near him. Then it makes perfect sense.
S: You’re kidding, right? No young person would be worried reading this. Many picture books about young people don’t have other actors in them.
C: Of course, yeah, it’s not scary, it’s a nice story. It is just that parents should probably be ready if their young bunny asks them these kinds of questions. It is about fun and imagination and not abandonment. Just in case, ya know.
S: Hmm, I think you have an overactive imagination sometimes Caramel.
C: Sometimes? I am offended. I have a perfectly normal imagination. And always.
S: Okay, sorry, didn’t mean it that way. You do have a big imagination.
C: The book is about Harold going north to find a Christmas tree, and then he finds himself at the north pole, and then he draws Santa and the whole Santa workshop, and then helps him make presents, then goes home, and realizes he forgot to find a tree, so he makes one. I think Crockett Johnson has an overactive imagination.
S: Yes I definitely agree. And it all makes the book suitably fun for the holidays. Which are about seven months away…
C: But it is never too early to dream of Christmas!
S: And it is actually time for some dreams. Bedtime, Caramel?
C: Yup. I think it is right about my bedtime.
S: So then let us wrap this up. What would you like to tell our readers?
C: Stay tuned for more book bunny reviews!
Caramel loved revisiting Harold while reading Harold at the North Pole by Crockett Johnson and hopes that many others will enjoy it this next Christmas or any other time of the year.
BookBunnies 