Caramel reviews Aggie and the Ghost by Matthew Forsythe

Today to honor this last week of October and therefore the week of Halloween, Caramel chose to review a book about a ghost and a girl who tried hard to get rid of him: Aggie and the Ghost by Matthew Forsythe, published originally in 2025. As usual Sprinkles is taking notes and asking questions.

Caramel reviews Aggie and the Ghost by Matthew Forsythe.
Caramel reviews Aggie and the Ghost by Matthew Forsythe.

Sprinkles: So Caramel, today we are talking about a book with ghosts because it is almost Halloween.

Caramel: Correction: One ghost! I mean at some point there are others, but the book is really about one ghost.

S: True. Okay, let us begin at the beginning. Tell us a bit about the book.

C: So this book is about a girl named Aggie, believe it or not.

S: Oh, I believe it. So then there should also be a ghost.

C: Yes. So Aggie somehow just gets herself a new home where she is living alone. But no, she is actually not alone. There is a ghost in the house.

S: Hmm, so Aggie is a little kid but is living alone. That’s kind of strange, right?

C: Yeah, I mean, I know there are kids in the world who do not have anyone, but they also do not usually have their own homes. Anyways, this is fiction, so we don’t ask too many such questions.

S: Right. So let us not ask those questions.

C: Anyways, so Aggie’s house is haunted. And Aggie gets annoyed that the ghost is stealing her socks and eating all the cheese, so she tries to make rules, but the ghost always breaks the rules.

S: So he is kind of a bad roommate.

C: Yeah, and Aggie did not even want a roommate! So, one day she gets fed up with him and goes out and the ghost follows her, and so she challenges the ghost to a tic-tac-toe game. And if he loses he has to leave the house, and if he wins and she loses, she has to leave the house.

S: That is one stressful game! And you know tic-tac-toe really well, right, Caramel? You even did a project on it!

C: Yeah, I know that it is really hard to win. If both of you know how to play right, and neither side messes up, you can’t win.

S: True. So anyways who wins the game?

C: Maybe I should not spoil the whole book.

S: But does it end happily? Like do they get to be friends?

C: Not quite. It does end happily, but I won’t say more.

Caramel is reading Aggie and the Ghost by Matthew Forsythe.
Caramel is reading Aggie and the Ghost by Matthew Forsythe.

S: Alright. Then maybe tell me this. You have read and reviewed another book by Matthew Forsythe before: Pokko and the Drum. Do you remember that book? Is this one similar to that other book at all?

C: Not really, but the pictures remind me of one another. So if you did not tell me that these two books were illustrated by the same person, I might still have guessed.

S: Yeah, there are some intangible similarities in style somehow…

C: Also both books have the weird not-making-sense factor, like a friendly ghost who steals socks and eats all the cheese, or a fox that won’t immediately eat a rabbit that is right next to it.

S: So this particular author creates really fun and interesting and impossible worlds, right? The other book was about a frog who played a drum, really loudly, and that on its own also did not make too much sense. But it was a lot of fun to read. Did you think this book was fun to read?

C: Yeah, it would especially be a good book for younger bunnies, and especially around this time, you know, with Halloween coming up! This is always a fun time to think about ghosts and this particular ghost is not scary at all. He is a bit annoying though. But he is kind of funny. He likes to wear Aggie’s socks and eats up all her cheese, and cannot follow any house rules Aggie sets up.

S: Yeah, I can see reading this book as a humorous way to celebrate Halloween!

C: Yeah, totally.

S: Okay, maybe this is a good time to wrap up this review.

C: Sure!

S: What do you want to tell our readers?

C: Stay tuned for more book bunny reviews! And happy Halloween!

Caramel enjoyed reading Aggie and the Ghost by Matthew Forsythe and wishes all the little bunnies a happy Halloween!
Caramel enjoyed reading Aggie and the Ghost by Matthew Forsythe and wishes all the little bunnies a happy Halloween!

Caramel reviews Pokko and the Drum by Matthew Forsythe

Today Caramel reviews a neat picture book first published in 2019: Pokko and the Drum by Matthew Forsythe. As usual Sprinkles is taking notes and asking questions.

Caramel reviews Pokko and the Drum by Matthew Forsythe.
Caramel reviews Pokko and the Drum by Matthew Forsythe.

Sprinkles: So Caramel, I see we have a neat picture book to talk about today.  

Caramel: Yes we do! It is about a frog named Pokko. 

S: Okay, so tell us a bit about Pokko. 

C: Pokko is a frog who was gifted a drum by her parents (bad idea on their part).

S: Why would that be a bad idea? And I think that is actually the very first sentence of the book, right?

C: Yeah, it was something along the lines of “The biggest mistake Pokko’s parents made was giving her a drum”. And it is later said (two pages later) that the reason is because the drum kept them from focusing, or really doing anything.

S: So the mom keeps trying to read, right? And a drum would be kind of loud I suppose. Remember how you played the trumpet for a while. That was loud. 

C: I at least had a thingy to make it quieter. I don’t think you can make drums quiet. 

S: That is true. Okay, so she is loud and so her dad suggests that she take it outside, right? 

C: Yes. And she does. But then she starts making some noise,or music I suppose. Then another animal joins her, and she plays louder. Then another joins her, again, and again, and by the time the sun sets, she has a whole band of animals following her and making music together, and they are so loud, the noise reaches her parents, all the way back in their home.

S: That sounds cool! So she makes friends with her music, right?

C: Yeah, it sounds cool, until a band member, a wolf, eats another one, a bunny.

S: Wait, that sounds kind of worrisome. 

C: Yes, it could be but in the book it is rather funny. Pokko scolds the wolf, saying that he can’t keep eating band members. The book is really funny. 

S: Wait, a wolf eats a bunny and you find that funny? 

C: Hmm, when you put it that way, as a bunny I should feel a bit concerned about the bunny who is eaten. But in the book Pokko scolds the wolf and the wolf behaves after that. And we move on. 

S: I see. I guess bad things happen in other books, too, and this is meant more as a funny thing rather than a tragedy.. 

C: Yep. 

Caramel is reading Pokko and the Drum by Matthew Forsythe.
Caramel is reading Pokko and the Drum by Matthew Forsythe.

S: Alright. So I read in another review that this book was about the power of “marching to the beat of your own drum”. Do you agree?

C: Yeah, I could see that. She is after all playing her own drum as she likes, and she keeps walking, and others join her beat. It is exactly like that actually!

S: So do you think there is a moral to the story?

C: I did not read it for a moral, it is really funny, and I did not tell you half of all the funny lines. But if I need to think about a moral, hmm, let me think… Maybe it is like you said, march to the beat of your own drum and you will find your friends and your own place in the world?

S: That makes sense.

C: And maybe your parents might try to hold you down, and just don’t let them?

S: Okay, maybe that is going a bit too far. After all the parents were the ones who got her the drum. 

C: Yeah, you’re right, that was maybe a little ridiculous.

S: But then again, they did try to suppress her music, so you do have a point Caramel. Sometimes even usually supportive parents might feel the children are going too far, making too loud music, and so on. And then maybe it is okay to push a little. Maybe. 

C: Maybe. And she does not disrespect the parents. Just continues to play her drum. She is making music. And music is beautiful. 

S: Yes. Agreed! Okay, so you thought this was really funny, you even read some of the lines out loud to me. Tell me now a bit about the illustrations. It seems the author is also the person who illustrated the book.

C: Yes. They are really funny. And they are very good at showing the characters’ feelings. You see how happy Pokko is when she gets the drum, for example.

S: I looked through the pages of the book, and thought the illustrations were funny and very lively. The colors are warm, and each page is quite a lot of fun to look at. So all in all, you enjoyed this book, right?

C: Very much so. I don’t get to read too many picture books anymore, but when I do, this is the kind of book I love. Funny and fun!

S: Okay, Caramel. I think this is a good place to end our review. 

C: Sure. 

S: What do you want to tell our readers?

C: Stay tuned for more book bunny reviews!

Caramel enjoyed reading Pokko and the Drum by Matthew Forsythe and recommends it to all little bunnies looking for a fun story about a little frog who loves music.
Caramel enjoyed reading Pokko and the Drum by Matthew Forsythe and recommends it to all little bunnies looking for a fun story about a little frog who loves music.