Marshmallow reviews The Witch’s Apprentice and Other Stories by Ekta R. Garg

The book bunnies love various retellings of the classic fairy tales of the Western tradition, and through the years, they have reviewed many books that offered different takes on them. They also have explored, these past few months, several books that collect together fairy tales from geographies from around the world. Therefore they were delighted to learn that they made it to the list of 30 Best Fairy Tale Blogs and Websites in 2025, curated by Feedspot, a blog aggregation site.

To celebrate, today Marshmallow is reviewing a brand new book of fairy tales: The Witch’s Apprentice and Other Stories, written by Ekta R. Garg. The book bunnies are delighted to be reviewing this book as part of a Blog Tour for The Witch’s Apprentice and Other Stories organized by WOW! Women On Writing.

Marshmallow’s Quick Take: If you like fantasy books that add on to the classic fairy tales and elaborate on their worlds, then this is the book for you! 

Marshmallow’s Summary (with Spoilers): The Witch’s Apprentice and Other Stories, as you can guess from the title, is a collection of short stories. There are a total of five stories in it. Each story picks up a well-known fairy tale or a classic folk tale, asks a followup question that you might have after reading it, and then goes on to offer a fantastical answer to that question.

The first story is set in the land of the Wonderful Wizard of Oz. The main character is the cousin of the Wicked Witch of the East. The Witch rules over Munchkinland and is the idol of the main character, who wants to become a witch just like her. This character, therefore, attends the school that trains students to be certified witches. Unfortunately, she is never summoned to take her final test, and the reasons she uncovers lead to the famous moment when Dorothy’s house smushes and crushes the Wicked Witch. The author offers this short story as a response to her question “When the tornado took Dorothy’s house to Oz, it landed on the Wicked Witch of the East and killed the witch instantly. What was the witch doing on the road in the first place?” I found this to be an interesting analysis and extension of the original story, opening the door to a related tangent that proved to be fun and entertaining to read.

The second story is about The Pied Piper of Hamelin. In this fairy tale, a musician promises to use his pipe music to get rid of the rats in the town of Hamelin. Even though he completes the job, the mayor refuses to pay the money owed, and the piper vows revenge. Later he comes back, plays his pipe, and lures all the children away from the town. The question this story seeks to answer is “What happened to the parents of Hamelin after that?” This story is much shorter than the others, and it left me feeling sad and somewhat unsatisfied.

But I really liked the story after it. This story focuses on the two conmen in The Emperor’s New Clothes, and I felt that it really helps flesh out the characters as three-dimensional people, rather than the flat caricatures shown in the more simplistic original story.

The second to last story is not quite about a fairy tale but rather a well-known nursery rhyme: Jack and Jill. The story goes into depth about the question “Why did Jack and Jill need that pail of water in the first place?” I found this story very touching in a heartbreaking way. It was very well developed and had a lot of nuance.

The final story is a mix of Goldilocks and Sleeping Beauty, which makes for an interesting cross-over. This time, the story answers two questions, one for each of the characters, and things get quite convoluted but in an interesting way.

Marshmallow’s Review: As you can probably tell, I highly enjoyed reading The Witch’s Apprentice and Other Stories. However, that was part of the problem; I liked the stories too much and was disappointed that some of them were so short. It was very satisfying to read explanations for some things that were confusing or vague in fairy tales. But, on the other hand, Garg’s stories opened up a whole new can of questions. I really wanted to hear more about the characters she developed and the new plots she started.

These stories were all fantastic and very quick and fun to read. I would highly recommend the book to readers of all ages, especially if you enjoy reading retellings of fairy tales, as in Beasts and Beauty: Dangerous Tales, Thornhedge, A Tale Dark and Grim, Tuck Everlasting, Ella Enchanted, Half Upon a Time, Thornwood or Glass Slippers. But I also would like the author to write extensions for these extensions—or more of these types of stories!

Marshmallow’s Rating: 95%.