Marshmallow reviews Night by Elie Wiesel

Today Marshmallow reviews Night by Elie Wiesel, first published in Yiddish in 1956 and in English in 1960. Wiesel won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1986 “for being a messenger to mankind: his message is one of peace, atonement and dignity”.

A small caveat: The book as well as the review below involve historical events that depict harsh realities. They may not be appropriate for younger readers.

Marshmallow reviews Night by Elie Wiesel.
Marshmallow reviews Night by Elie Wiesel.

Marshmallow’s Quick Take: If you are a person of reasonable maturity and ability to process and handle important historical events, then this is the book for you.

Marshmallow’s Summary (with Spoilers): Elie Wiesel was a young Jewish boy in Romania during the Second World War. The book is more or less a memoir of his youth.

Elie is a young boy, extraordinarily devout at a remarkably young age, seeking out a religious mentor in Moishe the Beadle. It is from him that the town of Sighet—located in Transylvania—first hears of the Nazis’ proximity. Since Moishe is a foreign Jew, he is forced to leave first. But he luckily escapes the Nazis who leave him for dead due to his bleeding, shot leg. Moishe walks on foot an unbelievably long journey back to Sighet to warn the very people who look down on him of how dangerous the Nazis are. None of the residents believe him. Elie worries for his mentor, as many adults around him say the Beadle is mad.

Many of the Jews of Sighet do not believe that the Germans could reach them. Others believe that the war would end before Germany’s reach expanded far enough to affect them. It is heartbreaking to say that they are wrong. The Nazis show up on Sighet’s streets within a matter of days.

The Jews are first forced into ghettos, condemned to smaller slums as though they are not deserving of being able to choose where to live. Soon they are forced out of their homes, able to take only what they could carry. They are made to wait on scorching sidewalks and soon after chased towards cattle carts that take them to the concentration camps. Elie and his family, which includes his father Shloma, his mother Sarah, his two older sisters, and his seven-year-old younger sister Tzipora, are taken to Auschwitz. He loses his mother Sarah and Tzipora to the gas chambers and the Nazis on the first day, though he does not know it for certain until later. He and his father are forced into labor camps and the horror continues.

Wiesel’s suffering is conveyed through his own testimony in Night. He and so many others, millions of Jews, Gypsies, and other undesirables in the Nazis’ eyes, suffered so much as the hands of humans who were in all aspects but one the same. This story is one that everyone must read.

Marshmallow is reading Night by Elie Wiesel.
Marshmallow is reading Night by Elie Wiesel.

Marshmallow’s Review: This book is simply vital. I think everyone must read it once they are old enough to understand why we must remember. Elie Wiesel is one of the strongest humans to walk this Earth and he is also one of the wisest. Through this book, he passes on the story of the Nazi camps and their horrors designed to exterminate the Jews. He describes things that provoke a deep silence after reading, a deep silence that necessitates thought and great gratitude that one is not in such a situation. Wiesel is a hero by the virtue that he survived. But there are so many who did not and, for their sake and Wiesel’s, this story cannot be forgotten.

Night was assigned as reading in my English class and that is one of the best decisions a teacher can make. This story has impacted so many and Wiesel is truly one of the few people who can be described as a master of prose and a witness of humanity. In words, Wiesel has described the indescribable.

Thanks to Wiesel’s wife Marion who translated it into English for a larger audience, Night is written in simple and clear language, with few ornate embellishments. The horrific events make it seem so already, so Wiesel says things in a way that never makes the story seem unreal.

It is really remarkable and heartbreaking that Wiesel never viewed himself as exceptional. He wonders several times why he survived. He says he was never special or had any sort of skills or attributes that made him deserving of life. But everyone is deserving of life and yet so many were robbed of it. It is truly heartbreaking. Yet, his thoughts and perseverance, his selflessness and his determination (though these words have lost much of their weight and meaning through superfluous use) make him one of the most admirable human beings. He cared unwaveringly for his father though they were both suffering. He never stopped looking after him, even though Wiesel himself thought he failed in this. Wiesel was truly, indescribably a remarkable person with a profound impact. His book Night must be read.

Marshmallow’s Rating: 200%.

Marshmallow rates Night by Elie Wiesel 200%.
Marshmallow rates Night by Elie Wiesel 200%.

Caramel reviews Nathan Hale’s Hazardous Tales #7: Raid of No Return by Nathan Hale

Today Caramel is talking to Sprinkles about Raid of No Return by Nathan Hale, published first in 2017. This is the seventh book in Nathan Hale’s Hazardous Tales series.

For Caramel’s reviews of the six earlier books, please check out: One Dead Spy, Treaties, Trenches, Mud, and Blood, The Underground Abductor, Big Bad Ironclad, Donner Dinner Party, and Alamo All-Stars.

Caramel reviews Nathan Hale’s Hazardous Tales #7: Raid of No Return by Nathan Hale.
Caramel reviews Nathan Hale’s Hazardous Tales #7: Raid of No Return by Nathan Hale.

Sprinkles: So Caramel, you are back this week with a new Nathan Hale book!

Caramel: Yep! This one is a WW2 one.

S: It is about the second world war, you mean?

C: Yep, it is about the U.S. bombing campaign on Tokyo, which is apparently called the Doolittle Raid today. It starts with a summary of how the second world war began and then the Pearl Harbor attack

S: That is interesting. Most of the earlier books in the series were about earlier parts of American history. So this is getting a bit closer to today. 

C: Sprinkles, it is not that close! The Pearl Harbor attack was in 1941. That is still the last century. 

S: You are right of course. It is also the last millennium!

C: Yeah, see, I was right! It is still quite ancient history, especially for a little bunny like me. 

S: True, for older bunnies like me who were born in the last century, maybe it feels closer. Anyways, so the book is about the battle in the Pacific Ocean then. 

C: It is even more specific than that. There is a little bit about how people viewed the Pearl Harbor attack, from both sides (American and Japanese), and then the rest of the book, we focus on the experiences of the pilots who flew the U.S. bombers over Tokyo. 

S: I see. I had of course heard about the Pearl Harbor event, but I had not read about this retaliation. From the Wikipedia article it looks like this was a very outrageous plan, not terribly likely to succeed–

C: Yes, but it somehow worked. They did manage to bomb some important military targets, I think. 

S: And the war escalated from then on of course. 

C: Yes.

Caramel is reading Nathan Hale’s Hazardous Tales #7: Raid of No Return by Nathan Hale.
Caramel is reading Nathan Hale’s Hazardous Tales #7: Raid of No Return by Nathan Hale.

S: Okay, so I am guessing that you were excited to read this book. It has been a few months since you last read a new Nathan Hale book. 

C: Yeah! And this one came in a box of three, like the other books I read from this series, and I loved all three!

S: Hmm, maybe you will review the others in the coming weeks. 

C: Maybe. If I do that, can we get the next three books? These were really good!

S: Sounds like a good deal to me. 

C: Okay, good. I know what I will be reviewing next week then!

S: Alright. Let us get back to this week though. So this is the seventh book in the series. Does the same framing story continue? I mean, the other books are all narrated by Nathan Hale, that famous spy who is about to get hanged. Is this one continuing the same thing?

C: Yeah, it is. 

S: I am a bit curious about how they will finish the series. I mean Hale did get hanged in the end. But maybe since this is for young bunnies, and there are so many other interesting historical tales to tell, maybe we will not ever get to those bits. 

C: Yeah, I hope that it never ends.

S: I know you love graphic novels and you love history and you love facts. This is just the right book series for you!

C: Yep, it is.

S: So then is it fair to say that you would recommend it to other young bunnies?

C: Yes! Any bunny who loves books or history or graphic novels would like these too! And you know, they don’t have to read them in order, so they can just jump right into any of them after the first one.

S: Great! Maybe this is a good place to wrap up this review. What do you think?

C: Sure. Then I can go back to reading and rereading the next book!

S: Sounds good to me. What do you want to tell our readers then?

C: Stay tuned for more book bunny reviews!

Caramel enjoyed reading Nathan Hale’s Hazardous Tales #7: Raid of No Return by Nathan Hale and is eager to read the next book in the series.
Caramel enjoyed reading Nathan Hale’s Hazardous Tales #7: Raid of No Return by Nathan Hale and is eager to read the next book in the series.

Marshmallow reviews Fearless by Lauren Roberts

Last year Marshmallow reviewed Powerless and Reckless by Lauren Roberts, the first two books of her Powerless trilogy. Then earlier this year, she reviewed Powerful, a novella that recounts events taking place in the same story world as the trilogy, involving some of the same characters that we met in those first two books. Today she is finally ready to talk about Fearless, the third and last book of the trilogy that was published just this April.

Marshmallow reviews Fearless by Lauren Roberts.
Marshmallow reviews Fearless by Lauren Roberts.

Marshmallow’s Quick Take: If you liked Lauren Roberts’ previous books in her Powerless series, then this is definitely the book for you—though probably you had already been waiting for it!

Marshmallow’s Summary (with Spoilers): [For most of the background, readers should probably begin with my review of the first book, Powerless, and my review of the second book, Reckless.]

At the end of Reckless, Paedyn Gray returns to Ilya as a prisoner believing she is approaching her own execution. Her captor is none other than her beloved Kai, who is bound by duty to bring her to his brother Kitt. However, it turns out that Kitt wanted Paedyn brought back to Ilya so he could propose to her. This is a shocking turn of events since she had killed their father—the king of Ilya—in the first book. (She did have a valid justification of self-defense.) After a while though, Kai has forgiven her. Kitt, on the other hand, seems to be stuck somewhere entirely different from the spectrum of forgiveness and hate.

Paedyn accepts Kitt’s proposal because she believes it will help bring equality in Ilya between the Ordinaries and the Elites. But even though she is now engaged to Kitt, Paedyn finds herself still pining for Kai. Once again, their love seems impossible. But they separately start to realize two things: first, Kitt has changed and no longer seems like himself, and secondly, they cannot be apart. Luckily for them, Kitt has arranged new Trials for Paedyn in order for her to prove herself as an Ordinary to the Elites of Ilya. She must retrieve ancient artifacts, gain the trust of foreign kingdoms, and make the ultimate sacrifice.

I won’t spoil more. But if you thought Roberts’ plot was complex in the first two books, you will be happy to know that the story ends in a most satisfactory way, though with many twists and turns along the way that I never saw coming. Will Paedyn, Kai, and Kitt all make it to their happy ending? Or will one or more get lost along the way?

Marshmallow is reading Fearless by Lauren Roberts.
Marshmallow is reading Fearless by Lauren Roberts.

Marshmallow’s Review: Fearless is a really complicated book that adds a lot of depth to the original story, the fictional world, Ilya’s history, the characters, and the series. Ultimately, the ending is bittersweet, but I can say that things are resolved pretty well. I was not disappointed with the end and I felt like this is probably the best way for the series to end without leaving a majority of the readers bawling with tears in their eyes. That said, it is still touching and emotional. In Fearless, Roberts reveals many layers of Ilya and the entire world that had been previously unseen. These revelations make the end an even more satisfying one because the story becomes a lot richer with detail.

I will say though that I did notice some things were a little too similar to the Hunger Games series to be coincidental. The Purging Trials of Ilya are almost carbon copies of Panem’s Hunger Games, and Paedyn in many aspects seems like a reflection of Katniss. I know a lot of readers are disappointed by these striking parallels. Many have pointed to several other books that Roberts seems to have “taken inspiration from.” I haven’t read all of the books they list, but I can see why some say that some aspects of Roberts’ work are a little suspiciously close to other peoples’ work. However, I found the plot twists in this book unique and these make all the difference. The twists in this third installment were so unexpected yet so well-executed that I could not put the book down till it was done.

I’m a little sad the series is over, and I do wonder if this emotional journey with Paedyn has been beneficial to me. (The series is rough on the tear ducts!) But overall, this was a very well-done conclusion for a very well-done series! Not all fans will be happy, but when have we readers ever agreed on an ending? Overall, I would recommend this third book because I really appreciate how, despite all the darkness in the previous books, it ends on a hopeful note.

Marshmallow’s Rating: 100%.

Marshmallow rates Fearless by Lauren Roberts 100%.
Marshmallow rates Fearless by Lauren Roberts 100%.

Caramel reviews Will the Pigeon Graduate? by Mo Willems

All the book bunnies love Mo Willems and his books about the Pigeon. Caramel even reviewed a couple of them for the book bunnies blog. See, for example, his reviews of The Pigeon HAS To Go To School and Be the Bus. Today he talks to Sprinkles about a brand new Pigeon book: Will the Pigeon Graduate? As usual, Sprinkles is taking notes and asking questions.

Caramel reviews Will the Pigeon Graduate? by Mo Willems.
Caramel reviews Will the Pigeon Graduate? by Mo Willems.

Sprinkles: So Caramel, today we are talking about a new book about the Pigeon!

Caramel: Yep, the best pigeon in the world is back!

S: You have read quite a lot of the other books about the Pigeon. You also reviewed two of them. What is this one about?

C: This one is about how the pigeon is growing up, and he is scared about the future after finishing school.

S: He is already graduating? How exciting!

C: Well, he had to go to school back in 2019 so I suppose it is time. 

S: You are right of course. At some point school ends and the rest of life begins. 

C: Yep, but I don’t like that idea.

S: Why not? 

C: I like being a young bunny going to school. I like it too much.

S: Why do you like it so much? I know you learn a lot of things at school every day and I know you like learning. But you can continue to learn outside of school. too. 

C: True, I guess you are right. But at school you have friends–

S: You can make friends after school, too. 

C: Yes, but school friends are the best! And at school, people tell you to do things, and you do them, and that is all the work you have. You do not have to earn money, save money, buy or rent a house, and all that adult stuff. 

S: I get that, Caramel. Growing up can be hard. And this is exactly what this book is about, isn’t it?

C: Yeah, I guess that the Pigeon is very smart.

S: How so?

C: Well, he knows finishing school means he has to start making important decisions and taking care of more things and being careful about all kinds of details and so on. 

S: That is very much true Caramel. But in the end he gathers up his courage and decides he is ready for whatever is coming his way, right?

C: Yes. 

Caramel is reading Will the Pigeon Graduate? by Mo Willems.
Caramel is reading Will the Pigeon Graduate? by Mo Willems.

S: I  am thinking this could be a really nice gift for someone finishing high school or elementary school or even college. What do you think? 

C: Yep, I think in a couple of years, Marshmallow might like it. There is even a little place in the inside cover of the book for a photo of someone graduating. We could put Marshmallow’s picture there. 

S: We could definitely do that. But we could also save it for you. You will also be graduating soon yourself. 

C: Yes, but I am going to go to another school right after. 

S: That still counts as moving to a bigger new world. That new school is bigger than your current one. And there will be a lot of changes. 

C: Hmm, I am not sure I am ready for a lot of changes. 

S: I know. We are not always ready but they come nonetheless. Anyways, there is still some time, but by the time that change comes, you will be ready. I am quite sure. 

C: Hmm, I hope you are right, Sprinkles. 

S: Remember how many years ago, you were about to change classrooms and get a new teacher and you were kind of anxious about it? We talked about it when we were discussing My Teacher Is A Robot

C: Yeah, that was a good book. And I did end up liking my new teacher a lot. Okay, maybe you are right. Maybe I can handle some changes, just like the Pigeon. 

S: Yay! That’s the right attitude Caramel! I think this is a perfect place to end this review. 

C: Alright by me!

S: Okay, what would you like to tell our readers then?

C: Stay tuned for more book bunny reviews!

Caramel enjoyed reading Will the Pigeon Graduate? by Mo Willems and thinks this book would be a great gift for new graduates.
Caramel enjoyed reading Will the Pigeon Graduate? by Mo Willems and thinks this book would be a great gift for new graduates.